Who Took The Climax Out Of The Torah?
From the first book of the Bible and Torah, in Genesis 12:7, God began to promise Abraham and his descendants that He would give them "the land", which is some places defined as the wadi in Egypt to the Euphrates River, and others as the Jordan River to the Mediterranean Sea, and yet others as simply Canaan. Regardless of the dimensions, God continued to make this promise to each generation, specifically warning Abraham that his descendants would suffer in a foreign land for four hundred years before that took place. To Isaac and to Jacob God reiterated the promise, and then the plot begins to develop when Joseph's brothers sell him as a slave to a caravan headed to Egypt. The results in his whole family eventually heading down there — an amazing story which you must read — and sets us up for the next book, Exodus, which describes the massive deliverance God performed for His people to free them from slavery in Egypt, lead them across the Red Sea on dry land, give them the law on the stone tablets, and lead them through the desert with a pillar of cloud by day and a pillar of fire by night, feeding them bread from heaven every morning except Sabbath. God continues to promise a land flowing with milk and honey and the people continually complain that the desert is no such land. Leviticus takes a break from the story to detail a number of hygenic and sacrificial rituals, and Numbers picks back up with more desert, more complaining, and more promises of the land. In Numbers, God sends twelve men to spy out the land, but only Joshua and Caleb believe that God is capable of giving it to them. So they wander in the desert for 40 more years. And finally, as we reach the end of what is currently called the Torah or the Pentateuch, we read the powerful book of Deuteronomy which seems to be a first person document from Moses recounting the whole journey and the laws of God and encouraging the people to obey the commandments so that they will be blessed when they inherit the land.
And then it's over. No land. No milk. No honey. We, the readers, are left on the eastern side of the Jordan River looking longingly across at the beautiful land that lies beyond it. The promise of God has not been fulfilled, and if we confine our study to the modern Torah we will never arrive there. That's a big disappointment as far as stories go. It's a cliff hanger with no sequel. The Torah is over. Thanks for reading. Maybe next time God makes a universe and writes a book He will make good on His promise to give us the land flowing with milk and honey, but in this universe we are simply left to wonder what was the whole point of what we just read. Do we get the land? Should we just go back to Egypt? They had leeks and onions there. Or should we just hang out here and look sorrowfully across that little winding river into the land we dreamt of for five long books?
Of course anyone who has seriously studied the Bible has recognized that there is actually another book called Joshua which contains the climax of the whole story where God brings the Hebrews across the Jordan River on dry land like the Red Sea and they conquer the land with magnificent success. The Amarna Letters are a recent archeological discovery that dramatically reinforce the historical account, such that I almost wish they were included after that book of the Bible the way they sometimes include maps. After reading Joshua, and particularly noticing the first part of Joshua 24:26, which says, "And Joshua wrote these words in the book of the law of God," one can't help but wonder why, if Joshua added these things to the book of the law, are they not in the book of the law that we have today?
Like many, I enjoy the story of David and Goliath, and I think, like many stories coming from prophets, it has deeper spiritual meanings. Of particular interest to me are the five smooth stones that David took from the stream to fight Goliath with. Why five? I think I remember at least one preacher trying to claim that Goliath had four brothers. I haven't found that anywhere in the Bible. Some might say the extra four were in case he missed with the first. Then why four extras and not three or five? But I think, as I suspect many others have thought, that the five smooth stones represent the five books of the law of God. Like when Jesus fed 5,000 men plus women and children with five loaves of bread. The modern Torah has five books, but the climactic book is omitted. So what are we to make of this? Something doesn't add up. Was another book added and Joshua removed? When? Why? By whom?
I'm not here to make allegations or to come up with conspiracy theories, but I will suggest this: include Joshua when you are reading the book of the law, and if you feel uncomfortable reading six books instead of the prophetic five, skip Leviticus. Leviticus, unlike the other five books, contains basically no history, and in Deuteronomy 24:8 Moses says, "Be careful against an infection of leprosy, that you diligently observe and do according to all that the Levitical priests teach you; as I have commanded them, so you shall be careful to do." So Leviticus possibly came from the priests, not Moses. Additionally, Leviticus is full of sacrifices, but in Jeremiah 7:22 God says, "For I did not speak to your fathers, or command them in the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt, concerning burnt offerings and sacrifices. But this is what I commanded them, saying, 'Obey My voice, and I will be your God, and you will be My people; and you will walk in all the way which I command you, that it may be well with you.'" Is it possible that Leviticus got boosted into the Torah and Joshua got booted out? It's a big claim, and it's probably too late in history to know for sure, but at least for our personal study we have the freedom to read what we want. As for me and my house, we will be reading the book of the law WITH the climax of Joshua and WITHOUT the priestly additions of Leviticus.
Fun fact: The English name Jesus comes from the Greek name for Joshua (in Hebrew Yehoshua), which is Iesous. In reality the two names are identical in both Greek and Hebrew. Needless to say this adds a layer of prophetic significance to the climactic book of the Torah.